Christian Gehrke
Fourth bracket, an hour later, straight down. Bright granite and green shadow in one frame.
HEAT SINKTested hot. Reviewed cool.
The Long-Term Test Issue

Fourth bracket, an hour later, straight down. Bright granite and green shadow in one frame.

Review

Three exposures, one photo

A case study of the Studio's HDR merge, tested on twelve real drone shots: four brackets of three exposures become four photos, with the sky and the shadows both kept.

More from HEAT SINK → The newsstand

Listen · 1:49Three exposures, one photo
Its three exposures, darkest to brightest.
Its three exposures, darkest to brightest.

My drone can take three pictures of the same view a second or two apart: one a little dark, one normal, one a little bright. None of them is right on its own. The dark one keeps the white granite and the sun on the water; the bright one opens up the shadows under the pines. Putting them together used to mean a desktop app. Now the Studio does it as the photos come in, and this Note is the test.

None of them is right on its own.

How it works

First bracket, 10:03. The merge keeps the deep blue water and the pale sand together.
First bracket, 10:03. The merge keeps the deep blue water and the pale sand together.
What went into it: the same view at −0.7, 0 and +0.7 EV, taken a second or two apart.
What went into it: the same view at −0.7, 0 and +0.7 EV, taken a second or two apart.

Here's how it works. I drop the shots into a Drive folder and the Studio brings them into my browser. It reads the time each one was taken, and shots within three seconds of each other become a candidate bracket. Before it merges anything, it checks that they really are one view at different brightness. A burst at a single exposure, or three different views, stay separate photos.

Then it lines them up, because a drone drifts, by comparing simple black and white maps of each shot, coarse to fine. Then it blends them: every pixel takes most from whichever shot exposed it best, where it's sharp and colourful, mixed at several scales so there are no seams or halos. A gentle contrast curve, a touch more colour, and it's done in a few seconds, in the browser. Only the merged photo is kept, with its location data stripped. The three originals never leave the folder.

The real test

Second bracket, a few seconds later and closer in. Every boulder under the surface keeps its shape.
Second bracket, a few seconds later and closer in. Every boulder under the surface keeps its shape.
Its three exposures. The darkest holds the white tops of the rocks, the brightest the shadows between them.
Its three exposures. The darkest holds the white tops of the rocks, the brightest the shadows between them.

The real test was twelve shots from the morning of September 12: four brackets of three, at −0.7, 0 and +0.7. Four photos came out. The drone held so still that every bracket lined up to the pixel, so nothing had to be cropped. The clearest result is the third one, with the sun on the water. In the normal shot 4.2% of the picture is pure white, and 6.6% in the bright one. In the merge it's under 1%.

Before trusting it with real shots, I tested it on made-up ones: two of my Tahoe photos darkened, brightened and nudged a few pixels apart. It found the drift exactly, and it refused the burst and the three different views I slipped in.

Third bracket, the hard one: sun on the water at the lower right. The merge keeps under 1% of the picture pure white.
Third bracket, the hard one: sun on the water at the lower right. The merge keeps under 1% of the picture pure white.
Its three exposures. The glare is already blown in the normal shot and spreads in the bright one.
Its three exposures. The glare is already blown in the normal shot and spreads in the bright one.

What the real folder found

The real folder found two problems the made-up one couldn't. It was dated the same day as another Note, so the Studio only offered to open that one; now a folder that only matches by date can start a Note of its own. And the new strips, the three exposures side by side, were cropped like photos and looked like the originals, so now they show whole, under the photo they made.

What I learned: test with the real thing. The made-up bracket proved the maths. The real folder found the two places where the Studio got in my way.

Verdict

Tested with the real thing

Twelve shots went in and four photos came out, with the white granite, the sun on the water and the shadows under the pines all kept. The drone held so still that nothing had to be cropped, and the hardest frame went from 6.6% pure white to under 1%.

The made-up bracket proved the maths. The real folder found the two places where the Studio got in the way, and both were fixed the same day. Christian's own lesson is the one to keep: test with the real thing.